Big Tech
Teknosfera Newsroom
Big Tech

The DRAM collusion suit survived, and AI can't be the alibi

A judge refused to dismiss the case against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron. The AI boom explains some of what happened to memory, but it shouldn't shield the oligopoly from scrutiny.

Published
November 15, 2026
Reading time
3 min
Categories
Big Tech

AI-generated image

Is it a coincidence when three companies that, according to the complaint, control nearly the whole market cut supply, skip expansion and adopt near-identical customer vetting while prices soar? A federal judge just said that question deserves a real answer, not a quick dismissal.

According to litnews.ai, Judge Noël Wise of the Northern District of California on November 14 denied in full the joint motion to dismiss a proposed class action against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron. She found the complaint plausibly alleges an agreement in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act. Nothing is proven. The allegations are accepted as true only at this stage, and the companies must answer by December 7, 2026.

The plaintiffs are 17 consumers and small businesses. They allege that the three firms, which held more than 91% of global DRAM revenue in the third quarter of 2025, cut production from late 2022 and shifted capacity to HBM. The complaint says conventional DRAM prices rose 171.8% in one year, and that none of the defendants announced meaningful expansion of commodity capacity.

"It was the AI boom" is an explanation, not an acquittal

The defense is intuitive: AI demand devoured memory, HBM is where the action is, and any rational company would pivot. We think that argument is probably a large part of the truth. But the judge noted something awkward. The customer-vetting practices the three allegedly adopted in January 2026 began after the AI boom and the HBM pivot were already underway, so demand alone doesn't explain them. She wrote that a pivot to HBM by itself "might not be sufficient," but that the related conduct tipped the balance.

That is the key point. Chasing AI money is legal and sensible. Doing it in lockstep is what the court found worth examining, along with the allegations that Samsung and SK Hynix refused long-term deals to major conventional DRAM customers and that none of the three expanded commodity capacity despite record prices. Her line about hawks "flying in formation" is a good one, and it captures the whole case.

The consumer is the one paying for the pivot

Memory is the part of a PC where you can't really shop around. If three suppliers decide that your DDR5 kit is the low-priority product, you don't get to vote. The complaint also says Micron announced on December 3, 2025, that it would close Crucial, its consumer brand. Whatever the legal outcome, that is a concrete loss of choice for people who build or upgrade their own machines.

We should be careful about what this ruling is not. It isn't a finding of conspiracy. The same three companies won an earlier round, DRAM II, when the Ninth Circuit affirmed dismissal in 2022. The judge also called the market's oligopolistic structure "neutral in the analysis," so a concentrated market alone won't sink anyone. And the history the complaint cites, a criminal cartel from 1998 to 2002 with fines of $300 million for Samsung and $185 million for Hynix, is background, not proof of anything today.

Regulators shouldn't wait for discovery

Our view: private litigation is slow, and the people hurt are paying now. Discovery may show internal documents that confirm or demolish the theory, and we would rather see that evidence than speculate. But competition authorities shouldn't treat a class action as a substitute for their own look. When a component becomes the bottleneck of the AI era and three firms hold it, parallel behavior deserves scrutiny by default, not as an afterthought.

There is a fair counterargument. Heavy capacity bets are risky, and being cautious about building fabs for a boom that might fade isn't sinister. That is exactly what discovery can test. If the companies have emails showing independent reasoning, this case should end, and they would be vindicated.

The verdict

The ruling is a procedural step, not a victory for anyone. But it matters because it shifts the burden of explanation to the companies that set the price of memory in every device. If you're buying RAM, don't expect relief from the courts soon. Do expect more questions about who decided that ordinary DRAM would stay scarce.

Debate topics

No topics yet: start the first one.

More stories