Internet & social
Teknosfera Newsroom
Internet & social

A "deal" is a claim, not a fact: price history is the only honest discount

Amazon's early Black Friday offers show why "40% off" means little without a price history. Shoppers should check it, and regulators should make reference prices auditable.

Published
November 17, 2026
Reading time
3 min
Categories
Internet & social

AI-generated image

What does "49% off" actually mean? Nothing, until someone tells you what it is 49% off of. That question is worth asking this week, because Amazon has started its "early Black Friday" offers ahead of its official Black Friday week, which Macerkopf reports begins on November 19. The German press is already full of red badges and big percentages.

We think the percentages are the least interesting part of the story. What matters is what they are measured against.

The discount is measured against a number the seller picks

Express.de describes Levi's items as up to 49% below the manufacturer's suggested retail price (UVP). Another Express piece lists coffee machines as up to 40% off, again against the UVP. A De'Longhi Magnifica S at €239.99 is "40% off" a €397.98 list price.

Notice the yardstick. It isn't what the product cost last week or last month. It is a suggested price that the manufacturer publishes, and in our view nothing in these articles tells you whether shoppers ever actually paid it. A discount against a number nobody may pay is not a discount, it's a framing device. The percentage is a claim whose denominator is chosen by the party that benefits from it.

That isn't a scandal by itself. A list price is a legitimate reference point. The problem is that the shopper is invited to read it as "what this normally costs", and the badge never says whether that reading is true.

Even a friendly review shows how uneven "deals" are

The most useful evidence comes from a source that did the boring work. Morgenpost says it compared the running offers against price trends, and it opens with a line we'd frame on a wall: a discount is not the same as savings. According to the paper, some "deal" prices sit barely below what you would have paid last week, while others hit levels not seen in months.

The details are telling. A pair of Philips Sonicare toothbrushes was only once about €3 cheaper this year. A Dyson V8 costs €249 at Amazon, yet eBay undercuts it by €10. A Philips OneBlade at €34.99 instead of €59.99 was occasionally about €5 cheaper last year, and the paper still calls it a good price. So the same sale event contains real bargains, marginal ones and plain advertising. The badge looks identical on all three, which is exactly the point.

Not every offer is smoke, of course. Macerkopf says the prices on some Amazon devices, such as Fire TV Sticks and Echo speakers, are already at their lows and won't drop further in Black Friday week. That may well be true. But it is the publication's claim, and it is exactly the kind of statement you can't verify without a history.

Make the history the default, not a browser extension

Today the burden is on the shopper. Outlets such as heise and Giga publish guides on tracking Amazon price histories to spot "fake discounts", and there are websites built just for that. That tells you something: when the consumer needs a third-party tool to check whether the headline number is honest, the market is not transparent.

Our position is simple, and it is an opinion. First, shoppers should treat any percentage as unproven until they have seen the price curve. Look at the lowest price of the past months, not at the crossed-out one, and check a rival retailer too. Second, regulators should require that any advertised reduction be tied to a verifiable reference price, such as the lowest price actually charged in a recent period, shown on the page. We can't tell you from our documentation what the current rules say in each country, so treat that as a policy proposal, not a description of the law.

Would retailers hate it? Probably, because the sale loses its theatrical effect. But a real deal survives scrutiny, and an honest seller loses nothing by showing the curve. The only offers that suffer are the ones that were never offers.

Verdict

Don't buy because a badge is red. Buy when the price is demonstrably low against its own history and you needed the product anyway. Until the history sits right beside the price, "deal" will remain a marketing word, and it's up to us, and eventually the lawmakers, to treat it as one.

#Amazon#Black Friday#e-commerce#consumer protection
Debate topics

No topics yet: start the first one.

More stories